
Herbert S. Lewis
Correcting the Record: Essays on the History of American Anthropology
Berghahn Books, 2024
198 pages, 7 illustrations, bibliography, and index
A PhD recipient from Columbia University’s Department of Anthropology (1963) with an extended and unfolding record of ethnographic research in the West Indies, Ethiopia, Israel, and the Oneida Nation of Wisconsin, an extensive publication record, and a teaching career at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, Herbert S. Lewis is a distinguished anthropologist and in recent years he has been a generous interlocutor for those of us trying to learn more of the history of anthropology. His purpose in Correcting the Record is to debunk the “half-century of mythology” that insinuates a) that American anthropologists were comfortably complicit in the practices of colonialism; b) that their efforts to “salvage” culture by documenting languages and cultural practices were in fact profoundly alienating to the people with whom they worked; and, c) that they were indifferent to the harsh circumstances facing the people they were studying. Lewis demonstrates emphatically: a) that very few American anthropologists contributed in any way to anything that might be reasonably labeled colonialism; b) that “salvage anthropology” produced an invaluable record of cultural practices that is increasingly used by descendant communities in linguistic and cultural revitalization efforts; and, c) that in general individual anthropologists established relationships with members of the communities with whom they conducted research and engaged in a variety of forms of reciprocity. Indeed, the vast majority of what he terms “classical anthropologists” were committed to challenging ethnocentrism and following scientific methods of inquiry that revealed the integrity of local life and exposed the arbitrary character of colonial rule.
Continue reading























